Syria Gets a New Government Tomorrow?
New Syrian Government
The latest gossip is that Syria's government has resigned and that a new government will be announced tomorrow. Abdullah Dardari will be Prime Minister and not Husseini. Dardari was in meetings all day with ministers trying to solidify the cabinet. Ghazi Kanaan, the controversial interior minister is out. One reason for changing the government now is because Mehlis plans to interview Kanaan. With Kanaan out, Mehlis will no longer be questioning a minister, which will be less of an insult to the sovereignty of the government.
Kate Seelye interviewed Kamal Labwani about the prospect of reform a few weeks ago when he had unsuccessfully attempted to launch his new political party. It aired on BBC's program, "The World," several weeks ago. She just sent it to me.
Last June, Syrian president Bashar al Assad promised major political and economic reforms. He made his pledge at a highly publicized conference of his ruling B aath party. But two months later, the Syrian government has launched yet another crackdown on political organizations. Kate Seelye visited Damascus and filed this report.
NAT SOUND UP: BIRDS CHIRPING….
TRACK 1: Syrian dissident Kamal Labwani recalls his plan to launch an independent political party in Syria…right in his own backyard.
ACT 1: I ORGANIZED A MEETING HERE, YES IN THIS PLACE, I COVERED IT AND GIVE CHAIRS…FOR ESTABLISH LDU, LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC PARTY. 12
TRACK 2: He says he invited more than 500 activists several weeks ago to his lush garden in the mountain resort of Zabadani. It’s about an hour outside of Damascus. He planned to call for more political freedoms and human rights here. . But independent parties are illegal in this one party state. And Labwani’s hopes for a political gathering in his leafy backyard were dashed.
ACT2: THE AUTHORITY CUT ALL THE ROADS, SURROUND MY HOME FOR 12 HOURS AND FORBIDDEN EVERYONE TO PASS, AFTER THAT THEY THREATEN ME, THEY THREATEN TO SEND A MUSLIM FANATIC GROUP TO ASSASSINATE ME. (HE LAUGHS. )20
TRACK 3: Labwani is a doctor by training and a longtime political activist, He has spent time in prison for his political views.. He says Syrians are beginning to doubt President Bashar al Assad’s commitment to reform. At a recent conference of the ruling Baath party, Assad promised to allow the formation of new political parties and to grant more press freedoms. He removed some longtime members of the Baath party opposed to reform and consolidated power. But since then, the regime has cracked down on Syrian opposition groups, like Labwani’s. It has closed down political gatherings and interrogated activists. Labwani says it's clear that Assad is reluctant to democratize his totalitarian state.
ACT 3 HE CAN PROMISE, BUT HE CANNOT DO. I THINK WE CANNOT WAIT A VERY LONG TIME. OUR GOAL IS TO SEE THE REGIME LEAVING. 11
TRACK 4: Joshua Landis is a professor at the University of Oklahoma. He currently lives in Damascus. He says the crackdown is a reaction to Syria’s humiliating retreat from Lebanon. Landis says President Assad is seeking to reassert his power.
ACT 4: BASHAR HAS COME BACK AND HE’S FLEXING HIS MUSCLES A LITTLE BIT NOW.
TRACK 5: But Landis says the muscle flexing has undermined the president’s credibility. He says when Assad pulled out of Lebanon, he made a promise to his people, which he hasn’t kept…so far.
ACT 5: HE SAID I’M GONG TO HAVE THIS NEW BAATH PARTY CONFERENCE AND I’M GOING TO GIVE YOU DOMESTIC REFORM. THIS WAS A DEAL THAT EVERY SYRIAN ACCEPTED. WE NEED TO FOCUS ON SYRIA FIRST. WE NEED TO GROW OUR ECONOMY, WE NEED REFORMS. BUT HE HASN’T. AND IF HE DOESN’T DELIVER ON THAT PROMISE, IT’S GONG TO BE BAD 20
TRACK 6: Disappointment over the lack of reforms is emboldening Syrians in unprecedented ways. Taxi drivers long fearful of the secret police, speak openly to strangers about their frustration with the state. A university student, inspired by recent protests in Lebanon, admits she is ready to demonstrate for change. A former chief of police calls for an American military strike to bring down the regime. Ayman Abdel Noor is a reformist in Syria’s ruling Baath party. He admits Bashar al Assad’s popularity is slipping.
ACT 6: BECAUSE OF THE BAD DECISIONS, AND BAD MOVEMENTS AND BAD PEOPLE WHO ACT IN THE REGIME IN A BAD WAY, THIS AFFECTS HIS IMAGE. 11
TRCK 7: But Abdel Noor insists political reforms are on the horizon.
***PLEASE CUT UMS AND AHS****
ACT 7: SYRIA WILL HAVE A NEW IMAGE TOTALLY IN 2007. BECAUSE WE ARE HAVING THREE ELECTIONS. FIRST LOCAL ADMINISTRATION, WHICH WILL BE TOTALLY FREE, SECOND WE’LL HAVE PARLIAMENTARY ELECTION, THIRD WILL HAVE THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION AND I THINK THEY WILL OPEN IT TO BE A MULTI-PARTY ELECTION. 23
TRACK 8: But 2007 is a long ways away and trust in the government is diminishing. Professor Joshua Landis says most activists in Syria have BEEN WORKING PEACEFULLY TO REFORM THE REGIME FROM WITHIN…SO FAR AT LEAST.
ACT 8: THE OVERWHELMING LINE THEY TOOK WAS WE WANT AMERICAN PRESSURE, IT CREATES A CERTAIN SPACE FOR US, SOME PUBLIC SPACE FOR US IN WHICH WE CAN TALK AND GIVES US SOME LEEWAY, BUT DON’T BREAK THE REGIME, CAUSE WE’RE GOING TO GET IRAQ. THE DANGER FOR PRESIDENT BASHAR AL ASSAD IS THAT’S GOING TO CHANGE AND IS THAT THEY’RE GOING TO SAY SQUEEZE AND BREAK. 22
TRACK 9:. But Landis doesn’t see a viable alternative to the current Syrian regime. . He says the opposition both inside and outside Syria remains weak and divided. Syrian dissidents challenge that view. They say a powerful coalition of Syrian Islamists, leftists, and liberals is coordinating in Europe. The dissidents say the coalition is planning for a future, democratic Syria. For the World, Kate Seelye, Damascus.
Here is a good profile of Mehlis by Hassan Fattah of the NY Times.
Solving Terrorism Cases With a Detective's Flair
By HASSAN M. FATTAH and SOUAD MEKHENNET
BEIRUT, Lebanon
WHEN Detlev Mehlis faced reporters earlier this month with a progress report on his investigation into the Feb. 14 assassination of the former Lebanese prime minister, Rafik Hariri, he had a clear message: we're winning.
17 Comments:
People of Syria! Raise up and demand freedom and get rid of your corrupt, dictatorship government! Any government will be better than what you have now! Although, I believe that you will choose a democratic government that if it did not do what it promised, you will get rid of it by a peaceful election!
Anyone that calls for peaceful regime change in Syria and no for foreign power help is a traitor of the Syrian people or a regime agent. Unless the United States comes to term with the limited use of force, pass the Syrian Liberation Act, organize a Syrian National Congress, fund the oppositions without any discrimination, there will be no end to the body bags coming from Iraq, assassinations in Lebanon and gross human and civil right violation in Syria, no stability, freedom or democracy in the Middle East. The people of Syria and the world are tired of this high wire circus act by this Alawites-Baathist regime of clown-dictator Assad.
This is the last and best chance the world is given to push forward and remove this last evil Baathist dictatorship. You snooze on this one, you loose. Take the right course of action and stop buying the false promises of these Baathist. They had 43 years to build Syria and establish a civil and economically sustainable country and they show for it now after all these years is deeds that not even Al-Capone will feel good about doing.
Dr. Ma'moune Fendi of AsharqAlawsat wrote the following excellent article regarding Syria, and its tough situation. I am copying it here with a hope that perhaps, some one in this selfish regime might understand it, and think back of the false hopes of their (enemy friend) Saddam Hussein, and understand that they have to first of all release all political prisonners now, not tomorrow so to involve the Syrian people themselves with what will take place soon. Let there be some one in this retarded regime understand that its survival is only guaranteed with the people on its side, and otherwise, the destruction of the regime and of Syria is coming:
ورطة سوريا
في الأسابيع الماضية تصاعدت التصريحات الأميركية التي تتهم سوريا بأنها قاعدة انطلاق للإرهابيين إلى العراق، تصريحات تدعو صراحة إلى عزل دمشق وعقابها، وتدعو إلى تشديد العزلة على دمشق. وكان آخر هذه التصريحات ما قالته وزيرة الخارجية كوندوليزا رايس التي حثت على «تكثيف» الضغوط الدولية على سورية، ووصفتها بأنها أصبحت معزولة فعلا.
هذه التصريحات تخفي وراءها ملامح خطة أميركية لعقاب سوريا، وأولى هذه الملامح التي بدأت تتشكل بوضوح هي عزل النظام السوري من سياقه العربي، ثم اتهامه مباشرة بعد تحقيقات ميليس بشأن اغتيال رئيس الوزراء السابق في لبنان السيد رفيق الحريري، يلي ذلك اقتراح قانون تصوت عليه الأمم المتحدة بعقاب سوريا اقتصاديا، ثم أخيرا الانقضاض على النظام.
هذه هي الخطوط العريضة للخطة والتي تبدو أكثر احكاما مما فعلته أميركا مع نظام صدام حسين، بعد أن تعلمت واشنطن من الأخطاء التي وقعت فيها مع نظام الرئيس العراقي المخلوع. وقبل أن أسهب في تفسير ملامح الخطة الأميركية، أتمنى من جماعتنا في سوريا ألا يتعاملوا مع هذه الخطة بنفس السخف والتخبط السياسي السابق، إن كانوا يريدون إنقاذ بلادهم من مصير أسود. فلا داعي أن يخرج علينا مسؤول سوري بعد قراءته تقريرا لسكرتير ثالث في سفاراتهم في واحدة من الدول الكبرى، ليقول بأن هذا مقال «يقطر حقدا أسود على سوريا». إنني أكتب عن سوريا بدافع الحب لأناس بسطاء مثلنا يريدون تربية أبنائهم وبناتهم في سلام.
وقبل أن أبدأ في التفاصيل أعبر عن دهشتي لهذا الفارق الكبير ما بين شعب مبدع وخلاق معروف عنه «الشطارة والتجارة» والمرونة عبر العصور، وحالة التيبس التي تبدو واضحة في تصرفات النخبة السياسية الحاكمة.
أبدأ تصوري لسيناريو معاقبة سوريا المعقد بالخطة الأميركية لعزل سوريا عن سياقيها الإقليمي والدولي. بداية تبدو سوريا معزولة عن كل دول الجوار العربي لها مثل العراق ولبنان والأردن. عزل سوريا عن لبنان ليس عزلا حكوميا فقط، وإنما اتخذ صيغة عداء شعبي لبناني لسوريا، فسوريا اليوم تصور على أنها عدو للبنان، وآخر ملامح هذا العداء جاءت في بيان صادر من لبنان يقول بأن الإسرائيلي أفضل من السوري عند بعض اللبنانيين، هذا من ناحية أول دولة مجاورة لسوريا. أما الموقف العراقي من سوريا فجاء واضحا في تصريح وزير الخارجية العراقي هوشيار زيباري لنيويورك تايمز، الذي قال فيه إن «سوريا تلعب لعبة خطرة في العراق». إذًا سوريا تصور كعدو للجار الثاني لها، فهي متهمة من الشعب العراقي والحكومة العراقية بأنها جار معاد، فهل تكفي دولتان تعاديان سوريا كي نقول بأنها حوصرت عربيا، بالطبع لا، لكن أيضا سوريا تبدو غير مرغوب فيها من طرف الأردن وهو جار ثالث، الجار الرابع وهو إسرائيل في حالة عداء محكم مع سوريا، ويحتل جزءا من أرضها.. سوريا أيضا على علاقة ملتبسة مع الدول العربية الكبرى مثل مصر والمملكة العربية السعودية.
إذًا قلعة العروبة لا تتحدث إلى العرب، أو حوصرت عربيا، وما تبقى لسوريا من علاقات هي مع دول مثل إيران وتركيا، دول الجوار غير العربية هي المنفذ الوحيد لقلعة العروبة. وهنا لا يمكننا إلا إن نفسر القلعة على أنها حصن منغلق يعزل النظام سياقه العربي وعن بقية العالم.
يتضح حجم المأساة إذا ما قارنا محاولات أميركا لعزل نظام صدام حسين، مع محاولات أميركا لعزل سوريا، لنجد أن أميركا نجحت في عزل سوريا وفشلت في عزل صدام عربيا. نظام صدام نجح على الأقل بأسلوب الرشاوى أن يخلق جوقة من المؤيدين له من الإعلاميين مدفوعي الأجر، الذين كانوا يقلبون هزائمه إلى انتصارات. سوريا حتى الآن فاشلة في أن تفعل ذلك. أكبر مدفعية صدام الإعلامية كانت ممثلة في فنانات سوريات كن يذهبن إلى بغداد كل أسبوع للاطمئنان على طفل العراق الكبير، فنانات طفن العالم العربي من المحيط إلى الخليج لتبييض وجه نظام قبيح. وللأسف لم يقمن بالشيء نفسه من أجل بلدهن الأم.
إذًا سوريا في وضع أسوأ من وضع صدام فيما يخص علاقاتها العربية. هذا من ناحية الحصار الإقليمي.
أما الشق الثاني من الاستراتيجية الأميركية فهو انتظار إدارة بوش حتى ينتهي ديتيلف ميلس من تقريره حول مسؤولية من قتل الحريري، وواضح من مجموعة الصفقات التي عقدها ميليس مع بعض رجال الأمن اللبنانيين والسوريين، أن التقرير سيأتي مدينا لسوريا ولحليفها اللبناني إيميل لحود ومن معه.
إذا ما ورد اسم النظام السوري في تقرير ميليس، فإن الولايات المتحدة الأميركية ـ حسب مصادر عليمة ـ ستتبنى قرارا في مجلس الأمن مؤيدا بكل من فرنسا وبريطانيا لفرض حصار اقتصادي على سوريا. هذا المقترح قد يصوت لصالحه كل الأعضاء باستثناء الصين التي قد تمتنع عن التصويت. ونتيجه هذا الحصار الاقتصادي ستكون أشبه بالحصار الذي فرضه العالم على ليبيا بعد اتهامها في قضية لوكيربي. وبذلك تعزل سوريا في دائرة أوسع من دائرة العالم العربي، حيث تجمد أوروبا شراكتها مع سوريا، ويبرر العرب عدم تعاملهم مع سوريا على أنه التزام بالشرعية الدولية، وربما بعد سنوات قد تخرق الحظر طائرة أو طائرتان تحملان غذاء لأطفال سوريا، هذا هو أقصى تصرف عربي ممكن.
يبدو من كل التصريحات الأميركية وكذلك الأوروبية، بداية من تصريحات الرئيس بوش ووزيرة خارجيته وكذلك تصريحات مستشاره للأمن القومي، وحتى تصريحات القيادات الأوروبية متمثلة في جاك شيراك، أن الخطوة التالية للحصار الاقتصادي هي حملة لتسويد وجه النظام السوري عالميا، مما يهيئ الرأي العام لقبول فكرة تغيير النظام، ولن يأتي هذا من خلال هجوم أميركي مباشر على غرار ما حدث في العراق، ولكنه سيبدأ بشكل تدريجي من العراق حيث تدخل بعض الوحدات العراقية والأميركية إلى الأراضي السورية بهدف تأديب الإرهابيين والقضاء على قواعدهم في سوريا، وبذلك يتحول جزء كبير من الأراضي السورية المجاورة للعراق إلى شيء أشبه بحال جنوب لبنان عندما كانت تحتله إسرائيل. وكما لم ينقص إسرائيل الذرائع للتحرك من الجنوب اللبناني حتى بيروت، فإن التحرش الأميركي بسوريا لن يتوانى في خلق ذرائع تدخله إلى دمشق. هذا هو السيناريو الذي يعد الآن فماذا أمام العرب وسوريا من خيارات؟
آخر تصريح سوري صادر عن السفارة السورية في واشنطن التي شجبت فيه السفارة الأعمال الإرهابية في العراق في أول سطرين، ثم خربت الموضوع برمته في بقية السطور، يوضح أن النظام لم يبرأ من أمراض الخطابات الطنانة، وما زال يستخدم لغة عفى عليها الزمن تعد طلاسم بالنسبة لبقية العالم، وربما للشعب السوري نفسه ولا يفهمها سوى نفر داخل النظام.
سوريا الآن في ورطة حقيقية. هذا هو لب الأمر وعموده. إذا ما العمل كي نجنب شعب سوريا دفع ثمن لقرارات خاطئة؟ الحل يكمن في اجتماع لكل الدول العربية بما فيهم سوريا، شريطة أن يكون السوريون مستمعين فقط، لا يسمح لهم ولو بخطبة واحدة من الخطب العصماء المطولة، الهدف من هذا الاجتماع هو منح سوريا غطاء سياسيا للخروج من الورطة الحالية، كذلك يقدم هذا الاجتماع إطارا يحفظ لسوريا ماء وجهها وهي تتراجع عن حزمة السياسات التي أوصلتها إلى هذا المأزق، سياسات تنم عن عناد وتيبس في الرأس. فدونما تراجع سوري عاجل، ودونما غطاء سياسي عربي عاجل أيضا لهذا التراجع، سنشاهد سوريا وهي تتجه بخطى واثقة في اتجاه الجحيم بسرعة البرق، ويبقى نفر من العرب المجانين يصفقون لها وهي تتجه إلى الهاوية لآخر قلعة للعروبة. أرجو ألا تفهم أيضا سوريا أن السيناريو سيطول وربما يلزمه سنوات قبل التنفيذ، وربما يرحل نظام بوش قبل أن يؤثر الحصار على سوريا. مثل هذا الفهم هو بداية الحسابات الخاطئة.
مأمون غندي
Not relating to Syria. But of interest to readers:
لندن : ذكرت صحيفة "الانديباندنت" البريطانية اليوم نقلا عن وزارة المالية العراقية ان وزارة الدفاع العراقية تعرضت لعملية نصب بقيمة مليار دولار الامر الذي اعاق بشكل خطير قدرات الحكومة على دحر التمرد. وقال الوزير المالية علي علاوي للصحيفة (وسط يسار) "ربما كانت هذه السرقة احدى اكبر السرقات في التاريخ". واوضحت الصحيفة ان القسم الاكبر من المبلغ "الذي ارسل الى الخارج واختلس" كان مخصصا لشراء اسلحة من بولندا وباكستان. ولكن بدل حصوله على تجهيزات متطورة كان اوصى عليها، حصل العراق على "قطع من المتحف". وذكرت الصحيفة ان بين هذه القطع سيارات "مصفحة" خرقتها طلقات نارية من رشاشات قديمة من طراز أي كي-47. كما استبدلت صفقة رشاشات من طراز "ام بي 5" يصل سعر القطعة منها الى 3500 دولار بنسخ مصرية لا يتعدى سعر القطعة منها 200 دولار. واوضحت ان "عددا من الجنود ورجال الشرطة العراقيين قتلوا لانهم كانوا مجهزين بشكل سيء". واضافت الصحيفة ان عملية النصب كانت كبيرة جدا الى حد ان مسؤولين في بغداد يعتبرون ان "العراقيين الضالعين فيها هم اشخاص وهميون وان "مرتشين" في الجيش او عناصر من المخابرات الاميركية قد يكونوا لعبوا دورا حاسما في الخفاء".
وابلغ رئيس الوزراء العراقي ابراهيم الجعفري بالقضية في ايار/مايو الماضي ولكن الخبر لم ينتشر بسرعة.
وقال الوزير علي علاوي ان ما بين 500 و600 مليون دولار اضافية قد تكون اختفت ايضا من وزارات الكهرباء والنقل والداخلية خصوصا.
Sorry about this lenghty post, but I found this article interesting and wanted to share it (the link would not work, sorry again).
Lebanon and Syria which needs the other more?
September 2005
Syria and Lebanon remain tightly dependent on each other for trade in goods and services. Executive weighs up to potential damage of extended economic fallout on both countries
As the border crisis between Lebanon and Syria unfolded over the last two months, the bars of Beirut and the family restaurants of the Old City of Damascus were host to boisterous and often heated conversations on how it was time for each country to "go it alone." The fallout from the late prime minister Rafik Hariri's assassination continues and nationalist sentiments are slowly eroding into the economic bedrock that has linked these two countries for centuries. As tensions are likely to continue for the foreseeable future, especially given the impending release of the findings of the UN investigation into Hariri's death this month, taking a closer look at what each side needs economically from the other is an important first step in understanding the options each country has at its disposal in weathering whatever crises might lie ahead.
Trade
In the first half of 2005, Lebanese exports to Syria totaled $105.7 million, representing 12% of all its exports. Imports of Syrian goods over the same period totaled $90.6 million, representing a mere 2% of all Lebanese imports and 2.6% of overall Syrian exports. Overall, Lebanon relies on Syria for oil products (43%), Mutton (15%), phosphates (8%), fruit and vegetables (6.4%), legumes (3.2%), milk and dairy (3%) and iron products (2.9%). Syria, in turn, relies on Lebanon for paper products (14%), cement (13%), aluminum (6%), marble (5%), sugar (3.2%), juice and water (3%), and alcohol (1.2%).
If economic relations were severed tomorrow, each side could go it alone in terms of import sourcing. However, this would lead to an increase in prices on both sides. Syrian oil and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) exports to Lebanon are extremely competitive, due to low transport costs and Lebanon's ability to tap into Syria's subsidized prices on some products. Lebanon's paper industry, for example, is one of the region's best, and sourcing paper products elsewhere from Turkey and Egypt would likely lead to high prices on the Syrian market.
The economic fallout of severing ties would impact not only Syria's state-owned energy sector, as many Lebanese have speculated, but also Syria's rapidly growing private sector, which accounts for around 65% of Syrian exports to Lebanon. To offset the losses of a Lebanese boycott, Syrian producers could find larger alternative markets in Turkey, with which Syria has just concluded a free-trade agreement. But as this agreement is phased in over a number of years, while customs on most products between Lebanon and Syria have been abolished, the reorientation of Syrian exports currently going to Lebanon would not be an easy process.
For Lebanon, the impact would be substantial, as Syria was its third largest export market in 2004 (after Iraq and Switzerland), totaling, according to Lebanese customs, some $145 million. Reorienting Lebanese exports would likely be problematic, due to the country's higher relative production prices that are the result of the Lebanese lira's current peg to the US dollar and the higher overall skill levels of Lebanese. Currently, Lebanese products are competitive on the Syrian market by virtue of the customs free environment between the two countries, as well as low transport costs. Just how fast exports to Syria could be made up for in the Arab Gulf in the face of stiffer competition from global producers is hard to determine.
Getting to market: Transit
In many ways, the fact that Damascus chose to heighten its "security" restrictions on the Lebanese frontier at the same time that the new "anti-Syrian" government in Beirut was taking shape should not have come as a surprise. It is in the transit of goods that the Lebanese-Syrian economic relationship takes on a much different and largely geographic dimension. With a border to the north and east with Syria, and a southern border with Israel that has been closed since 1948 (except during periods of Israeli occupation), and western coastline facing the Mediterranean, Lebanon is completely dependent on Syria for getting its goods to market overland. Coming to grips with Lebanon's overland transit issue involves a good deal of crunching of numbers from both Lebanese and Syrian sources. According to the Lebanese Ministry of Economy, overall Lebanese exports (including services) totaled $2.5 billion in 2004. In terms of general trade (i.e. material goods excluding services and tourism) exports, Lebanese customs figures total some $1.747 billion. Of Lebanon's top 16 export markets, 10 are in the Middle East ($1.339 billion), including Iraq ($255.5 million), Syria ($145.2 million), UAE ($135.3 million), Turkey ($127.3 million), Saudi Arabia ($112.8 million), Kuwait ($67.4 million), Jordan ($62.8 million), Egypt ($39.5 million), Qatar ($30.3 million) and Iran ($21 million).
Just how much of those goods traverse Syria? According to the Syrian Central Bureau of Statistics (which breaks down transit trade by country of origin and country of destination), Lebanese transit trade through Syria in 2004 totaled around $702 million, with $347 million going to the UAE, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Jordan, and $355 million going to "other countries," including Iraq and Iran. Combining Lebanese figures on exports to Syria ($145.2 million) with Syrian figures on transit trade of Lebanese origin ($702 million) means that around $847 million (around 49%) of all Lebanese general trade (and 33% of overall trade) in 2004 involved goods crossing the Syrian frontier. Another interesting development has come in the area of transit of goods through Lebanon. According to Lebanese customs figures (which are not broken down by country of origin or country of destination, making it difficult to determine directions in the flow of trade), transit of goods totaled a record $355 million in 2004, up from a mere $69 million in 2001 and $185 million in 2003. The reason? Given that transit trade quadrupled starting in July 2003, it seems safe to assume that Lebanese shippers have tapped securely into supplying US-occupied Iraq. In the first six months of 2005, transit totaled around $113 million.
Sanctions busting and smuggling
Figures on "informal" trade between Lebanon and Syria are difficult to come by, with estimates ranging from hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars per year. According to Syrian law, its importers are required to directly import goods from their country of origin using Syrian air and sea ports. The only exception to this rule exercised by Damascus concerns the current US export ban (all goods with 10% US content other than food and medicine) on Syria. Syrian companies seeking US components are then allowed to purchase these goods in other markets. According to Syrian businessmen, Lebanon and Dubai rank as the top two sources for the "re-export" of US goods to Syria, given each country's higher standards of living and sophisticated markets. While the range of re-exported goods to Syria is as wide as whatever is on offer in the re-export market, Syrian businessmen say they rely on Lebanon largely for high-tech components vital to computers and networking.
Until very recently, goods carried by Lebanese and Syrians across the frontier for "personal" use were substantial. Syria's military and security presence in Lebanon had one very powerful ancillary benefit: customs procedures on both sides of the border were extremely lax. Furthermore, after Syrian President Bashar al-Assad came to power, historically tight customs procedures were relaxed, leading at first to the construction of several "superstores" in Chtaura where Syrians heading home could stop and purchase anything from food to high tech goods. Business was so brisk over the last few years that Assad's cousin, Rami Makhlouf, constructed a massive Duty Free in the neutral zone going into Syria, complete with a supermarket, electronic shop, pharmacy, and even a Dunkin Donuts. The Duty Free facility was constructed on the inbound side of the road to Damascus, flying in the face of Duty Free procedures throughout the world that aim at passengers exiting the country.
Exactly how much this trade was worth is unknown, but it was systematic enough that shopkeepers in Damascus openly admitted being supplied with various goods that officially fall under Syria's import restriction list. This process has become more difficult, however, as shortly after security procedures tightened on the Syrian frontier, Syrian customs reverted back to its old, pre-Bashar self. Today, passengers crossing to Syria are having difficulty even bringing in bottles of Lebanese wine or in some cases water. And many consumer goods previously available in Syrian shops have disappeared.
So in terms of overall informal trade, Syria is much more dependent on Lebanon's free market for sourcing the goods that are fueling Syria's growing appetite for globalized products. Import regulations have changed, however, and now products such as Coca Cola, Pepsi and even KFC are available in Damascus via Syrian suppliers and the recent restrictions on the Lebanese border could be the first step towards cutting off Lebanon's traditional role as Syria's consumer window to the outside world.
Labor
The issue of Syrian labor in Lebanon has been discussed so many times in the Lebanese press that to go into it in depth here would not add anything new. Suffice to say, Lebanon needs cheap, low to medium skilled labor both to carry out the government's ongoing reconstruction plans, as well as to service private sector businesses and individual homes. As Syrians live right next door, and often have Lebanese family, their availability on the Lebanese market is something that long predates Syria's 29-year sojourn in Lebanon. Estimates of Syrian laborers in Lebanon vary between 400,000 to 1 million.
The Lebanese state has not made it easy to introduce other foreign laborers to the country, due largely to Lebanon's lengthy and expensive residency and work permit procedures, which inclusive of insurance total some $1800 per head per year. Such fees have increased in tandem with the Lebanese state's desperate attempt to deal with its debt problem.
Much less attention has been paid to the role of Lebanese labor in Syria. According to the Syrian-Lebanese Higher Council, some 100,000 Lebanese currently work in Syria. However, this figure is widely believed to be inflated, even by some Syrian government officials. Getting a handle on Lebanese labor in Syria faces the same difficulties in forming good estimates on Syrian labor in Lebanon, as many Lebanese and Syrian families and households overlap. This being said, the utilization of Lebanese expertise was highlighted during a recent crackdown on "illegal" Lebanese labor in Syria. Beginning in July, Syrian police showed up at the door of Syria's new private sector banks, as well as the country's two mobile phone companies. All non-Syrians without work papers were duly taken to the Lebanese border and "dropped off."
According to sources in Syria's private sector banks, Lebanese play a vital role in the training of Syrians staffing the new banks. Syrians have little experience in banking, following 40 years of a state monopoly over finance. Implementing international bank risk procedures has been a major challenge to the new banks, and deposits are piling up. Private bankers say that Lebanese are vital to training credit managers in several respects. First and foremost, risk procedures vary from bank to bank (or what is called "credit culture"), and Syrian private banks with Lebanese involvement have to learn first hand from their more experienced Lebanese counterparts just what to lend and under what circumstances. Second, of course, Lebanese have the language skills necessary to best explain the institution's procedures.
Finance
Millions of dollars have been flowing into Syria's private sector banks following their opening in 2003. Nevertheless, Lebanon remains Syria's piggy bank, with estimates varying widely from the hundreds of millions into the billions of dollars in deposits. And as Lebanese institutions are involved in the vast majority of Syria's private banking ventures, the link between Lebanese and Syrian finance seems set to remain enmeshed for the foreseeable future.
Bankers say going it alone would be disastrous to both economies. For example, Lebanese institutions known to have substantial Syrian deposits, including BLOM, BEMO, Audi, and Byblos, are heavily invested in Lebanese Treasury Bills. On the Syrian side, the regulatory environment for private banks is still restrictive, as the Syrian state tries to deal with substantial issues concerning interest rates, exchange rates, and the introduction of liquidity facilities. A majority of Syrian traders still use L/Cs from Lebanese banks to import goods. In the end, bankers says that separating the two systems - something that did not even happen during Lebanon's civil war - would be virtually impossible.
So which neighbor needs the other more? A run down through the issues above shows that Lebanon and Syria enjoy (or suffer from) a complex, symbiotic economic relationship. In many ways, each side thrives off the weaknesses of the other - perhaps the main conceptual pillar of trade throughout the world. But unlike other countries in the region, Lebanon and Syria's economies have substantial overlap - especially in the areas of labor and finance - which serve as the mortar keeping this complex system alive. Reform in Syria will help allow the country to stop depending on Lebanon to service basic needs - a fact that Lebanese should take to heart as they consider the implications of their country's long-term economic future. And it is only in looking to that long-term future, and implementing reform plans to achieve set targets, that Lebanese will be able to carve out an economic independence to match their new political reality.
By Andrew Tabler
I am sick of the Kuwaiti Al-Seyassa.
Its latest news? BAshar sent Asef Shawkat to offer Paris a deal that includes Syria recognizing Israel and recognizing Golan as ISraeli terretory. I have more news to Al-Seyassa newspaper, Sheikh Hamburger and his extra nutritioned bedouins are no better than the disease we have here in Syria.
People will revolt, and change is coming. Syria is going to face days that it has never witnessed since its independence.
the syrian people dont believe the americans ,they know that this regime was an american israeli creation.
Yes MF, agree on the Hamburger Fatso Bedouins but Al Siyassah has been pro and for the people of Syria ever since I lived in Kuwait in 1970.
And for Adonis for the Syrians/Ishtar for the Babylonians/Ashtret for the Cannanites and Hebrew / Mary for the Christian. You are right about this trust. It don't exist.
Agha
Asseyasseh Newspaper is saying that Dardary is being investigated for espionage with the Mossad.
Why does thye Mossad need to spy in the Assads? I can;t undersand it!
2- There is an article by an Egyptian Writer at AsharqAlawsat.com who, I think has copied the exact article of Joshua Landis that was published at teh NY Times, and translated it saying it is hers. One can notice the great resemblence.
http://www.asharqalawsat.com/leader.asp?section=3&article=324386&issue=9793
She is Mona Tahawi, an Egyptian woman acting smart!
Done. I doubt she will ever even come close to write an article contain the word Syria in it after
she read our email to her.
Please guys, put one paragraph from the article and a link instead of copy pasting the whole thing.
I am reading and was told of a huge demand on U.S. Dollars in Syria. Any news from our friends inside Syria about that issue?
Also, what are the latest news on Maher?
رغم قرار القضاء بنزعه من الأرض
اعتقال سوري ومحاميه بسبب رفع تمثال لحافظ الأسد من أرض بمدينة حلب
دبي- العربية.نت
أعلنت مصادر حقوقية سورية اعتقال الأجهزة الأمنية في مدينة حلب (شمال سوريا) للمحامي عادل سرجيه وذلك للتحقيق معه في قضية تنفيذ حكم قضائي يتعلق برفع تمثال الرئيس السوري الراحل حافظ الأسد من أرض موكله السيد عبد المجيد شبارق الذي تم اعتقاله أيضا.
وأوضحت المنظمة العربية لحقوق الإنسان، في بيان وصلت "العربية.نت" نسخة منه، أن اتحاد الفلاحين في محافظة حلب قام بوضع التمثال في أرض دون الحصول على إذن مسبق من مالكيها، الذين "بدورهم رفعوا دعاوى قضائية وحصلوا على قرار قضائي مكتسب درجة القطعية برفع التمثال من الأرض".
وتابعت المنظمة في بيانها "قام المحامي عادل سرجيه بوضع الحكم موضع التنفيذ أصولا وقد تم إخطار اتحاد الفلاحين برفع التمثال لكنهم لم يستجيبوا, فقام مالك الأرض إضافة إلى ذلك بتوجيه كتاب إنذار موجه عن طريق الكاتب بالعدل يخاطب اتحاد الفلاحين بضرورة رفع التمثال حتى يتسنى لهم استغلال أرضهم فلم يستجيبوا".
وختمت المنظمة في بيانها أن عدم استجابة اتحاد الفلاحين دفعت صاحب الأرض ومحاميه إلى "رفع التمثال ووضعه في مكتب عادل سرجيه سليما, وعقب ذلك تم توقيف مالك الأرض وسرجيه".
Prof. Josh:
Is this a regime that is worth taking one second of your time to defend it?
If you read Arabic, then may be you can tell us if you would like to have this regime govern you personally based on the news item I have posted above.
Regards.
That is not new in this catagory of arrest by the Alawites-Baathist regime. In Emesa (Homs), few years ago a small corner market (Bakalieh) owner was arrested and tortured for six month.
Upon a visit by the Evil Hafez to Homs for pomp speech, the Mukhabrat went on a spree all over the town posting gigantic murals of this little coward leader who caved in to Israel, Saddam and the Turks on a blink. one of mural boards was posted on the sign of this small one room grocery market, covering the entire sign. The 60+ years old shopkeeper dared to slide the mural about a foot to the right to show the first 2 letters on his sign advertising the store name. that afternoon, a jeep come in loaded with security thugs and drags the old man out of his shop. Customers were stunned and started pleading with the thugs to leave the old man or at least let him notify his wife. They refused. Six months later the man appeared in his shop with multiple bruses and disfuguration and skeleton body.
Whatever happened to that new Government? Mossad did not finish the list of new ministers and give it to Bashar?
Must be golf week for Mossad. Have some mercy on Bashar he is stressed, pacing the floor and wringing his swetty hand waiting for your list of new minister Mosaad, common stop the golf for now.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home